Accountability · Published Calls

The track record.

Every fair-value call we have published, marked to market, alongside the claims we have already graded in public — including the ones we got wrong.


Open fair-value calls

Marks as of 22 Aug 2026, 20:59. “Called” is the return to fair value the note implied on its publication date. “Since call” is what the stock has actually done since. “To FV now” is the distance still left. “Closed” is how much of the called distance the market has travelled — above 100% means it has gone past us.

PublishedNoteFair valuePrice at call CalledPrice nowSince call To FV nowClosedResolves
05 Aug 2026 The First Print, Scored — SpaceX (SPCX) SPCX $78.51 $115.59 -32.1% $136.74 +18.3% -42.6% -57% OPENOct 2026
04 Aug 2026 The Fade Line, Measured — Palantir After the Print PLTR $149.00 $154.22 -3.4% $179.84 +16.6% -17.1% n/m OPENOct 2026
03 Aug 2026 The Fade Line — What Palantir's Price Actually Demands PLTR $112.00 $125.24 -10.6% $179.84 +43.6% -37.7% -412% OPENOct 2026
03 Aug 2026 The First Print: What $111 Still Has to Believe — SpaceX (SPCX) SPCX $66.50 $112.18 -40.7% $136.74 +21.9% -51.4% -54% OPENOct 2026
31 Jul 2026 Strategy (MSTR) Q2 2026: The Drain, Made Visible MSTR $94.00 $93.28 +0.8% $121.40 +30.1% -22.6% n/m OPENOct 2026
31 Jul 2026 Apple (AAPL) — The Control Group AAPL $208.00 $308.91 -32.7% $309.69 +0.3% -32.8% -1% OPENOct 2026
31 Jul 2026 Amazon (AMZN) — The Honest Machine AMZN $142.00 $271.58 -47.7% $259.55 -4.4% -45.3% 9% OPENOct 2026
30 Jul 2026 The $116 Billion Question — Microsoft (MSFT) MSFT $403.00 $451.10 -10.7% $483.61 +7.2% -16.7% -68% OPENOct 2026
30 Jul 2026 Meta (META) — Paying Twice META $370.00 $539.03 -31.4% $552.95 +2.6% -33.1% -8% OPENOct 2026
30 Jul 2026 Coinbase Q2 2026: The Scissors Open Wider COIN $102.00 $154.60 -34.0% $189.20 +22.4% -46.1% -66% OPENOct 2026
24 Jul 2026 Tesla (TSLA) — Four Times the Finish Line TSLA $91.00 $319.69 -71.5% $363.93 +13.8% -75.0% -19% OPENOct 2026
23 Jul 2026 Alphabet (GOOGL) — The Convention Price GOOGL $256.42 $317.69 -19.3% $345.10 +8.6% -25.7% -45% OPENOct 2026
22 Jul 2026 GE Vernova — The Sold-Out Decade GEV $672.00 $985.03 -31.8% $957.29 -2.8% -29.8% 9% OPENOct 2026
17 Jul 2026 NVIDIA — Priced for the Clock Not Breaking NVDA $163.00 $202.81 -19.6% $215.38 +6.2% -24.3% -32% OPENOct 2026
16 Jul 2026 Oracle (ORCL) — The Round Trip ORCL $114.00 $124.21 -8.2% $146.80 +18.2% -22.3% -221% OPENOct 2026
16 Jul 2026 CoreWeave (CRWV) — The Thin Floor CRWV $60.00 $72.91 -17.7% $87.68 +20.3% -31.6% -114% OPENOct 2026
13 Jul 2026 Robinhood (HOOD): The Price Is a Growth Commitment HOOD $87.00 $109.86 -20.8% $108.53 -1.2% -19.8% 6% OPENOct 2026
13 Jul 2026 Block (XYZ): The Most Misread Name in Crypto XYZ $83.00 $78.72 +5.4% $82.17 +4.4% +1.0% 80% OPENOct 2026
05 Jul 2026 Coinbase (COIN): The Right Company at the Wrong Price COIN $102.00 $165.48 -38.4% $189.20 +14.3% -46.1% -37% OPENSep 2026
05 Jul 2026 Circle (CRCL): The Price of Distribution CRCL $50.00 $64.62 -22.6% $88.53 +37.0% -43.5% -164% OPENSep 2026
28 Jun 2026 Strategy (MSTR): What Are You Really Buying? MSTR $86.00 $82.31 +4.5% $121.40 +47.5% -29.2% n/m OPENSep 2026

Scored in public

Claims a later note has already graded against the evidence, with the verdict as it was written — confirmations, partial misses and outright misses together.

08 Aug 2026 · The Price Nobody Charged

Households funded the spending increase from savings, not credit: of $1,185bn of consumption growth in the year to April, $591bn (~50%) came from the saving rate falling 5.5% to 3.0%, against $106bn (9%) from total consumer credit — roughly five to one

CONFIRMED — the pre-registered falsification test (household-hhdc-q2-preregistration) resolved 11 Aug 2026: the Q2 HHDC printed cohort delinquency transitions roughly stable vs Q1 — card 90+ by age 18-29 +0.41pp offset by 30-39 -0.42pp, auto flat, aggregate 30+ flows inside their two-year plateau — so households had not pivoted from savings to credit. The sequencing claim survives its first dated checkpoint; the ongoing watch passes to the revolving-credit and saving-rate-floor triggers.

03 Aug 2026 · The Fade Line — What Palantir's Price Actually Demands

Q2 print mapping, stated pre-print: >=$1.86B revenue (+85%) is slow-fade evidence; consensus $1.81B (+80%) is one tick down the curve; <$1.78B is the first faster-than-breakeven datum; an FY26 guide above ~$7.9B is the strongest slow-fade signal available tonight

SCORED 2026-08-04 in pltr-fade-measured — revenue $1.935B (+93%, accelerating) cleared the $1.86B slow-fade bar and the $1.81B consensus by a wide margin; FY26 guide $8.15B cleared the $7.9B bar. The strongest possible slow-fade reading: the pre-registered re-weight fired (bull 25%->35%, bear 30%->20%), fair value restated $112 -> $149.

27 Jul 2026 · CLARITY's Endgame: Recess, the September Window, and the Midterm Freeze

Stage one of the ladder: ~2% signed by the recess, against a market at ~3c — with 'a filed cloture motion or a locked September date' named in advance as the pre-recess bull tells

CORRECT, in near-agreement with the market. H.R. 3633 was not law by the recess — resolved No 10 Aug 2026 (Kalshi Sep-1 leg at 1c). Both named bull tells fired in the final pre-recess hours: Thune moved to proceed and filed cloture on 8 Aug 2026 (CR S4557), and the Senate locked the cloture vote for 2:15 p.m. ET, 15 Sep by unanimous consent. The disagreement now sits in the open stages, inverted: Kalshi Oct-1 leg 11c vs house ~18%, 2026 leg 23c vs house ~35% — the house is above the market for the first time in the franchise.

27 Jul 2026 · The Staircase Turn

PCE three-month annualized momentum has risen every month from 2.7% (Nov 2025) to 6.3% (May 2026) — six readings, six increases, no interruptions — while the market prices only ~28% odds of a July 2026 hike and ~71% hold

SPLIT — the market half scored clean (the 71% hold came in). The momentum half broke the next morning: June PCE, released 30 Jul, printed 3.07% three-month annualized against 6.31% in May, ending the six-month climb on the seventh reading. Accurate as description at publication; inverted as a forward signal inside 24 hours.

27 Jul 2026 · The Staircase Turn

None of the Fed's three dials argues for a cut: headline PCE +4.1% YoY, unemployment 4.2% with initial claims 187k (a 15-year low), HY OAS 2.79pp near three-year tights, Chicago Fed NFCI -0.55

CONFIRMED on the conclusion, SOFT on one input — the committee held and not one member voted to ease, so no dial argued for a cut. But the note's labor dial leaned on the 187k print as a 15-year low; it was genuinely the lowest since 2011 and yet a single-week trough after five weeks of 209k-230k. The 4-week average through 25 Jul is 202,750, above the note's own 200k threshold. Correct call, cherry-picked input — logged so the next note quotes the 4-week average.

27 Jul 2026 · The Staircase Turn

Policy is negative in real terms — effective fed funds 3.63% against 4.1% headline inflation — while the 10-year at 4.69% is doing the tightening on its own

NARROWED — the June vintage cut headline YoY to 3.67%, so the real policy rate went from roughly -0.5pp to roughly flat (3.63% vs 3.67%). The negative-real-rate framing was true on May data and is now marginal. The 10-year leg held: 4.67% on the decision, 4.68% the day after, against 4.69% at publication.

27 Jul 2026 · The Staircase Turn

The cut branch is dead on this data: prediction markets price cuts at a fifth of a penny, and there is no version of the July 2026 meeting where the Fed eases

CONFIRMED, emphatically — the 29 Jul FOMC held at 3.50-3.75% with three dissents (Hammack, Kashkari, Logan) all preferring a 25bp HIKE. Zero votes to ease. The 'coiled spring' read was right, but it surfaced in the vote tally, not in the statement language the note told readers to watch: inflation stayed 'remains elevated,' never shifting to 'has risen.'

27 Jul 2026 · The Staircase Turn

Strongest counter-case (carried honestly): core three-month momentum has decelerated three straight months from 4.8% to 3.5%, and the 5-year breakeven at 2.18% has been falling since spring — the expectations anchor is the single best argument this is not the 1970s

VINDICATED — the note's self-argued counter-case is the reading the data endorsed. Core three-month annualized fell to 2.89% in June, a fourth straight deceleration, and the 5-year breakeven sat at 2.24% on decision day versus 2.18% at publication: no anchor repricing in either direction. The hedge outperformed the thesis.

19 Jul 2026 · Structural, or Just Winter?

Bear claim 1 — 'The gamblers have left crypto for good': speculative money now goes to prediction markets and zero-day options instead, permanently

MOSTLY REJECTED. True this month, but 'for good' fails — speculative money has 'left Bitcoin forever' before every recovery in its history, and the prediction-market boom is smaller than it looks (~85-87% of Kalshi volume is sports). Weather, not climate.

19 Jul 2026 · Structural, or Just Winter?

Bear claim 2 — 'Bitcoin's power is worth far more running AI, so the energy is leaving mining for good'

TRUE, BUT ABOUT THE WRONG THING. The 10-20x gap and the conversions are real and permanent — for the mining stocks. But the difficulty adjustment makes mining more profitable whenever miners leave, so the network heals itself. A fact about ten companies' business models, not about the asset.

19 Jul 2026 · Structural, or Just Winter?

Sub-claim: energy is not actually leaving mining — hashrate is near its all-time high (~1,043 EH/s) even though revenue per unit of hashpower is down ~46% Y/Y

REJECTED — the middle step of the bear argument mostly hasn't happened, and even if it did the last step doesn't follow.

19 Jul 2026 · Structural, or Just Winter?

Sub-claim: the signed AI contracts are NOT a source of miner flexibility — ten companies, 19 deals, ~3.9 GW, ~$96B, almost nothing renewing before 2031

THE BULL CASE AS USUALLY TOLD FAILS. The accurate version that holds: flexibility lives in the ~20 GW of secured-but-uncontracted pipeline (~5x what is under contract) plus a yearly signing rhythm.

17 Jul 2026 · The Depreciation Question

As the record 2024-25 capex vintages land, reported depreciation must grow sharply at every high-dose name regardless of schedule

CONFIRMED (Q2'26): depreciation accelerated 4-for-4 — MSFT +56%, META +46%, GOOGL +43%, AMZN +42% (AWS alone +67%) — against control stock Apple at +16%.

17 Jul 2026 · The Depreciation Question

Guided capex holds or rises; the model assumed Microsoft would spend ~$115.0bn in FY2026

CONFIRMED: Microsoft FY2026 actual capex $115.9bn per the FY26 10-K — a 0.8% miss against the published assumption.

17 Jul 2026 · The Depreciation Question

Companies keep five-to-six-year server lives through the fastest hardware-obsolescence cycle in computing history — thirteen disclosed extensions since 2020 against exactly one correction the other way (Amazon, Feb 2025)

CONFIRMED: no server-life change disclosed at any of the five plus Apple in the Q2'26 filings. Microsoft instead extended building lives 15 to 25 years effective FY2027 — the fourteenth extension against one reversal.

17 Jul 2026 · The Depreciation Question

Rank the companies by dose (capex / net income) and you rank them by earnings overstatement — nine concordant pairs out of ten — and the dose is rising at every hyperscaler

CONFIRMED: every dose rose — MSFT 0.63 to 0.87, GOOGL 0.69 to ~1.19, META 1.15 to ~1.96, AMZN 1.70 to ~2.34; Apple's control dose held at 0.07.

28 Jun 2026 · Strategy (MSTR): What Are You Really Buying?

The real risk is a slow funding drain: a permanent ~$1.55B/yr preferred cash coupon against a zero-yield asset with no operating free cash flow

UNDERSTATED — mstr-q2-2026 restates the coupon at $1.76B/yr, 13% higher in one quarter.

28 Jun 2026 · Strategy (MSTR): What Are You Really Buying?

No margin-call channel exists — the debt is unsecured with no BTC pledged

PARTIAL MISS — mstr-q2-2026 finds 26 June WAS a margin event in shadow leverage built on top of STRC, where broker-dealers cut advance ratios and cascaded liquidations. Leverage migrated outside the balance sheet and was not modelled.

23 Jun 2026 · Will the CLARITY Act Be Signed Into Law Before August?

P(H.R. 3633 signed into law on or before 31 July 2026) ~13%, range 5-20% — a weighted blend of the Kalshi before-Aug contract (~18%), an outside-view reference class (~8%), a conditional-gate model (~6.3%) and converted full-year markets

CORRECT, and correctly below market. The before-August contract expired near zero (<1c on ~878k volume) with no Senate vote scheduled; resolved No on 1 Aug 2026. Both the direction of the below-market call and the reference-class logic behind it (a bill that had missed every prior deadline) scored. Scored in clarity-act-endgame v2.0.


Under test next

Dated checks the published notes set for themselves. 50 dated tests are on the book; the nearest 12 are shown. Each is checked automatically and graded when it lands.

DueTestNoteWhen
28 Aug 2026 NVDA 10-Q · OpenAI reappears The Neocloud Fuse in 6d
31 Aug 2026 COIN · Circle renewal Coinbase (COIN): The Right Company at the Wrong Price in 9d
31 Aug 2026 CRCL · Coinbase renewal Circle (CRCL): The Price of Distribution in 9d
01 Sep 2026 AAPL Ternus capex inflection Apple (AAPL) — The Control Group in 10d
03 Sep 2026 HOOD event-contracts cert petition Robinhood (HOOD): The Price Is a Growth Commitment in 12d
04 Sep 2026 Third consecutive L&H payroll decline The Price Nobody Charged in 13d
08 Sep 2026 STRC back to par Strategy (MSTR) Q2 2026: The Drain, Made Visible in 17d
15 Sep 2026 CLARITY cloture vote 15 Sep CLARITY's Endgame: Recess, the September Window, and the Midterm Freeze in 24d
15 Sep 2026 PLTR 10-Q: customer count / NDR check The Fade Line, Measured — Palantir After the Print in 24d
30 Sep 2026 AAPL Siri AI launch Apple (AAPL) — The Control Group in 39d
02 Oct 2026 CLARITY September window CLARITY's Endgame: Recess, the September Window, and the Midterm Freeze in 41d
29 Oct 2026 MSFT building-life filing check The First Invoice in 68d